Katelyn Schaffner

🌷 Spring has sprung! 🌼 As we embrace the beauty of blooming flowers and sunny days, let’s not forget about protecting what matters most. 🌈 Is your insurance up-to-date? 🛡️ Whether it’s home, life, or auto, spring cleaning isn’t just for your closet! 🌱 Let’s give your coverage a refresh for great coverage all season long! 💚 #SpringIntoProtection

Welcome to the Katelyn Schaffner State Farm Agency in Middletown, NY. I’m a lifelong resident of Orange County, and I’m proud to serve the community I grew up in—especially Cornwall, where I’ve lived for my entire life.

I began my State Farm career in 2016 and opened my own agency in August 2021. Today, my team and I proudly help customers with their insurance needs across New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania—and locally across the Middletown area and surrounding towns throughout Orange County and the Hudson Valley.

Communities We Serve (Middletown + Nearby Towns)

Locally, we serve drivers and families throughout Middletown and surrounding communities including: Middletown, Cornwall, Circleville, New Hampton, Wallkill, Mechanicstown, Bloomingburg, Goshen, Chester, Warwick, New Windsor, Otisville, Maybrook, and Florida (Orange County).

If you’re searching for “car insurance near me in Middletown, NY” or you want an agent who knows the area, we’re here to help.

Insurance Coverage Options We Help With

Whether you’re protecting your first car, insuring your home, or preparing for the future, we offer guidance on coverage options that make sense for you. Our office helps with:

• Auto Insurance

• Motorcycle Insurance

• RV Insurance

• ATV Insurance

• Boat Insurance

• Renters Insurance

• Pet Insurance

• Home Insurance

• Life Insurance

• Health Products

We take time to explain your options clearly—so insurance doesn’t feel confusing. Our goal is to make the process feel straightforward, with dependable service and ongoing support for customers in Middletown, NY and beyond.

A Local Approach to Insurance (Not One-Size-Fits-All)

Insurance is personal. That’s why we focus on communication, clarity, and helping you review coverage with confidence—whether you’re looking for a new policy, adjusting coverage, or exploring ways to protect what matters most.

Ready to review your coverage or get a quote? Call our office—we’d be happy to help you protect your family, your home, and your vehicles.

Questions & Answers

Q: Do you serve Middletown, NY and nearby towns?

A: Yes. We’re based in Middletown, NY, and we also serve Orange County communities such as Cornwall, Circleville, New Hampton, Wallkill, Mechanicstown, Bloomingburg, Goshen, Chester, Warwick, New Windsor, Otisville, Maybrook, and Florida.

Q: What types of insurance do you offer?

A: We help with auto, home, renters, life, health, and more—including coverage for motorcycles, RVs, ATVs, and boats—plus pet insurance.

Q: Can you help me review my existing policy?

A: Absolutely. We can review your current coverage to help ensure you have protection that fits your situation—whether you’re in Middletown, Cornwall, or another nearby town.

Q: Do you help with bundling policies?

A: Yes. Many customers choose to bundle policies for convenience and to help align coverage across their vehicles and home.

Q: How do I get started?

A: Give us a call to discuss your needs. We’ll walk you through options and help you choose coverage with confidence.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

1) What should I have ready for an insurance quote?

To get started, be ready with details about the vehicle(s) and/or property (address for home/renters, drivers on the policy, and relevant information about coverage needs). If you’re not sure, we’ll guide you.

2) Do you offer auto insurance for drivers in Middletown, NY?

Yes. We provide auto insurance for drivers across Middletown and the surrounding Orange County area.

3) Can you help with motorcycle, ATV, or boat insurance?

Yes. We offer specialized coverage options for motorcycles, ATVs, and boats, helping customers protect their vehicles and gear.

4) Do you offer renters insurance in the Middletown area?

Yes. If you rent in Middletown or nearby towns like Wallkill, Chester, Warwick, or Goshen, we can help you review renters coverage.